How a buyer tests a seller's equipment list
A seller's equipment list is a statement of what the seller says is being sold. A buyer tests it five ways before closing: that each item exists, that the seller can deliver title, that it runs, that nothing is missing from the list, and that the value attached to it holds up against the market. An independent equipment appraisal covers all five in one inspection. Lukes & Lukes is an independent Machinery & Equipment (M&E) appraisal firm; a NEBB-certified Machinery & Equipment Appraiser (CMEA) prepares every report, and a second senior appraiser reviews it.
By Jared Lukes · CEO & lead appraiser
Buying a business with equipment? Request an appraisal →
What the list is, and what it is not
Most sellers hand over one of three documents: the fixed asset register from the books, the depreciation schedule from the tax return, or a list written for the sale. Each was built for a different purpose, and none was built to be checked by a buyer.
The register records what was bought and when. It carries cost and book value, which are accounting entries and not market values. Assets sold, scrapped or traded in can still sit on it, and assets expensed in the year of purchase may never have been on it.
Test 1: does each item exist?
Walk the floor with the list and match every line to a machine. The match is made on the data plate: make, model, year and serial number. A description such as "CNC lathe, shop 2" identifies nothing a second person can verify.
Lines that cannot be found are listed separately from lines that are found with a different serial number. The first group is a question for the seller. The second is often a transcription error, and sometimes a unit that was swapped.
Test 2: can the seller deliver title?
Equipment on a seller's list may be financed, leased, held on consignment, or owned by a customer or a related company. A lender with a security interest usually files a UCC financing statement, and the filing office for the seller's state shows who has filed against the seller. Vehicles and trailers carry a certificate of title that names the owner and any lienholder.
An appraiser records what the inspection shows, including lender tags and lease plates, and lists the open questions. Searching the record and confirming title belongs to counsel and the closing agent.
Test 3: does it run, and what shape is it in?
A list says nothing about condition. A machine can be on the register at its full original specification and stand idle for want of a spindle, a controller or a certification. Hours, meter readings, maintenance records and a demonstration under power are the evidence. Condition is observed and written down per asset, since the same model in two conditions sells at two different values.
Test 4: what is missing from the list?
Lists leave things out. The usual gaps are attachments and buckets, tooling and fixtures, dies and molds, spare parts, software licenses that run a machine, forklifts and small vehicles bought outside the equipment budget, and fully depreciated assets that nobody carries any more. Each can be worth money to the buyer and each affects what the purchase agreement should cover.
The reverse also happens: items on the premises that belong to a customer, a landlord or a leasing company. These are separated out before a value is placed on anything.
Test 5: does the value hold up?
Book value and asking price are the two values sellers usually attach to a list. Neither is market evidence. A value a buyer can rely on comes from sold prices for comparable machines, adjusted for age, hours, condition and configuration, and it is stated for a defined premise: fair market value in place and in use, or a liquidation premise if the assets will be sold off. The difference between those is covered in FMV, OLV, FLV and NOLV, explained.
When the machinery is bought as part of a business, the same schedule supports the purchase price allocation. A list that has been tested line by line is also the schedule a lender or an auditor will ask for.
What the buyer should have in hand
- The seller's list in a spreadsheet, with the source named: register, depreciation schedule or sale list.
- The latest depreciation schedules and a list of disposals since the last year-end.
- Lease agreements and loan statements that show which units are financed and who holds the security interest.
- Maintenance records, inspection certificates and recent repair invoices for the major units.
- The draft purchase agreement, so the equipment schedule matches the assets the contract conveys.
- Site access for the walk, with someone from the seller who can start and run the machines.
Common questions
Answers, up front.
Can a buyer rely on the seller's fixed asset register?
As a starting list, yes. As evidence of what exists, who owns it and what it is worth, no. The register records cost and book value from the seller's accounting, and it can carry assets that have been sold or scrapped and omit assets that were expensed. The buyer tests it against the floor and the market.
The seller's list says "CNC lathe, shop 2". How is that line tied to a machine?
Each line is matched to a machine by the data plate: make, model, year and serial number. Photographs record the plate. Lines with no machine, machines with no line and serial numbers that differ from the list are reported separately.
Does an equipment appraisal confirm that the seller owns the equipment?
No. The appraisal records what the inspection shows, such as lender tags, lease plates and titles, and flags open questions. A UCC search and a title review are done by counsel or the closing agent.
We have a signed letter of intent. When should we test the seller's equipment list?
Before the price and the equipment schedule are fixed in the purchase agreement, which is normally during due diligence. A tested list lets the agreement name the assets conveyed and lets the lender and accountant work from the same schedule.