Diminished Value: 3 Things to Know Before You Settle
1:05 · published August 4, 2026 · Jared Lukes, CMEA
The three things to know before accepting an insurer's diminished value offer after a collision repair: the accident history follows the VIN, the insurer's first number is not evidence, and documentation decides the outcome.
Need this number for a live file? Request an appraisal →
Key moments
Jump to the part you need.
Transcript
Every word, if you would rather read it.
Your car was hit, repaired, and looks perfect. It is still worth less, and the market knows.
One. The history follows the VIN. A documented accident lowers resale value even after flawless repairs. That loss is called diminished value, and in most states you can claim it.
Two. The insurer's first number is an opening position. It is not evidence. A claim needs an independent appraisal built on real comparable sales.
Three. Documentation decides the outcome. Inspection, repair records, and market comparables, assembled in a report that holds up when challenged.
Lukes and Lukes appraises diminished value nationwide. Impartial, inspection backed, USPAP compliant. Start the conversation at lukesappraisals.com.
Ready when you are
Need this number for a live file?
Send the asset list and the reason for the appraisal. We confirm the premise and scope before any work begins, and we never quote a value before inspection.